Tag
Revisionism
The theory that the early sources on Islam cannot be trusted, and the evidence against it.
-
5 Western scholars of Islam and where Muslims differ with them
Geiger, Caetani, Jeffery, Goitein and Armstrong: 5 Western scholars who shaped the study of Islam, what they argued and where Muslims disagree.
-
Schacht, isnads and the dating of hadith: 8 answers
Hadith were forged and Muslim scholars said so first, but writing began early, chains were tested and the quoted figures mislead.
-
The revisionist case: 6 answers on manuscripts, coins and Mecca
Early manuscripts, coins, inscriptions and the location of Mecca: 6 answers on what the revisionist case shows and what it does not.